How Bad Can a Tooth Be and Still Get a Crown? What Dentists Need to See

Wondering if your damaged tooth can be saved with a crown? Learn the criteria Nassau County dentists use to determine if a crown is still an option.

The "Save or Extract" Dilemma

We see it often: a patient comes in with a tooth that has been through a lot. Maybe it has a massive cavity, a deep crack, or an old filling that has finally failed. The pain is real, and the worry is even worse: "Is this tooth too far gone? Do I have to pull it?"

It is the most critical decision in restorative dentistry. While our goal at Meadowbrook Dental Care is always to save your natural tooth whenever possible, there is a limit to what modern dentistry can repair. A dental crown is a powerful tool, a custom "helmet" that covers and protects a damaged tooth, but it needs a solid foundation to work.

So, where is the line? How bad can a tooth be and still be saved? In this guide, we will walk you through the specific requirements our dentists look for when deciding if a tooth can be rescued with a crown or if it’s time to look at replacement options like implants.

The 3 "Must-Haves" for a Successful Crown

For a crown to last (and be worth your investment), the underlying tooth must meet three non-negotiable criteria. If the tooth fails any of these, placing a crown would be like building a house on quicksand.

Solid Bone Support: The tooth is only as good as the bone holding it in. If severe gum disease (periodontitis) has destroyed the bone around the roots, the tooth will be loose. Putting a crown on a loose tooth won't tighten it; it will eventually fall out. We need to see healthy, stable bone levels on your X-ray.
Enough Healthy Structure Above the Gum: A crown relies on friction and cement to stay in place. It needs something to grip onto. We generally need at least 2mm of healthy natural tooth structure sticking up all the way around the gum line. If a tooth is broken off flat at the gum line, there is nothing for the crown to hold.
Healthy Roots: The roots are the anchor. If the root is fractured vertically, infected beyond repair, or reabsorbed, the foundation is compromised. No matter how beautiful the crown is on top, a broken root means the tooth is doomed.

When a "Bad" Tooth Can Still Be Saved (The Hero Procedures)

Just because a tooth looks terrible to the naked eye doesn't mean it's hopeless. Modern dentistry has a few tricks to save teeth that seem "too bad" at first glance.

Core Buildup: If you have a huge cavity that leaves a hollow shell, we can use a strong composite material to fill the center and rebuild the tooth's core. This creates the solid shape needed to support a crown.
Crown Lengthening: What if the tooth is broken right at the gum line? In some cases, we can perform a minor surgical procedure called crown lengthening. By reshaping the gum and bone tissue, we expose more of the natural tooth structure, creating the necessary "grip" for the crown.
Root Canal Therapy: If the damage has reached the nerve and caused an infection, the tooth isn't lost. A root canal removes the infection, and a post can be placed inside the canal to help anchor the core buildup, allowing us to crown the tooth successfully.

The Hard Truth: When Is a Crown a Bad Idea?

Sometimes, we could technically place a crown, but we shouldn't. At Meadowbrook Dental Care, we value honesty. We will not recommend a procedure if we believe it has a poor long-term prognosis.

We may recommend extraction instead of a crown if:

The Crack Goes Below the Gum Line: A vertical root fracture is a fatal blow to a tooth. It cannot be sealed, and infection will constantly seep in.
The Decay is Too Deep: If the cavity extends deep onto the root surface, far below the bone level, it becomes impossible to seal the crown properly. A crown that can't be sealed will just leak and rot again quickly.
The Cost-Benefit Ratio is Poor: If saving the tooth requires a root canal, gum surgery, a post, a core, and a crown, the cost might exceed $4,000 for a tooth that still has a guarded prognosis. In these cases, a dental implant might be a stronger, more predictable, and cost-effective investment.

Get an Honest Second Opinion in Nassau County

It is impossible to judge a tooth's "saveability" just by looking in the mirror. You need X-rays and a clinical exam to see what is happening under the gums.

If you have been told a tooth needs to be pulled, or if you are worried a broken tooth is hopeless, come see us. We are experts at saving damaged teeth, but we are also honest about when it’s time to let go.

Don't guess with your health. Schedule a consultation at Meadowbrook Dental Care in Mineola or Plainview today. We will take a look, explain your options clearly, and help you make the best choice for your smile.

Book Your Consultation